Future of Work
Immigration
Belonging
Social Isolation
Gender
Climate Policy
Social Media
Food
Supply Chains
Circular Economy
Community
Nature
Waste
Identity
Housing
Art
Climate
Fashion
Media
Wellbeing
Health
Sport
Culture
Technology
Care System
Government
Politics
Law
Urban Design
Inequality
AI
Education
Sumayyah Azhar
BASc Year 3

Student Transience and Community Belonging

What Factors of Student Transience Effect Community Belonging
Community
Culture
Housing
Belonging

Summary

Methods
Ethnography
Data Science
Disciplinary perspectives
Environmental Geography
Social Psychology

Studentification is a large issue within University cities today. Commonly thought as the first step to gentrification, studentification is the process by which the sociospatial makeup of an area changes due to an influx of students from a nearby higher education provider. This issue commonly is treated as an ‘us v.s. them’ issue, pitting local communities and students against one another.

I argue that this isn’t how it should be. I hypothesise that the transient nature of being a student affects the ability to feel a sense of community belonging, and as such any opportunities for community integration. This then leads to the issues surrounding community resilience, cohesion and displacement students are typically blamed for.

This project opens dialogue between these groups, and in the process of doing so, finds some overarching problem areas stemming from student transience that could be tackled.

Approach and Methodology

In September, there is an increasing amount of change happening for students at higher education providers; from haggling deposits back, moving to completely new areas with new sets of people to beginning the new academic year at university. This study came to me from this context, whereby I was witnessing a disparity between my peers who hadn’t constantly moved throughout our time at university, and those that had.

This context was paired with moving to Peckham myself, an area in the midst of atypical urban regeneration stemming from gentrification - current Southwark council plans include creating large multi-story apartment housing (of which only 20% will be affordable) in the centre of Rye Lane, the cultural heart of Peckham. As well as having had multiple conversations with acquaintances involved in the save Brick Lane campaign. The impact the system surrounding student has on both students and local communities is a context I am inescapably embedded in - the study came from this.

The accessibility of this topic allowed for me to use ethnography as my qualitative method. I had already read a lot about studentification at this point; so sent out an invite to my social network to participate in my study. The ethnographic methods chosen were hyper-local demarcation (Joy White’s method involving analysing a local area through the overarching themes: town-planning, soundscapes, legislation and community) and intimate conversations which emerged authentically throughout the process of being taken around my friends’ homes and local areas.

From the ethnographic fieldwork, six themes emerged: Economic practice, recreation, decoration, amenity, maintenance and cleanliness and temporal artefacts. More information was then gathered on these six themes using a survey I created and sent through my social network. The results of this survey was then analysed using multiple linear regression and ANOVA testing for statistical significance of the relationship of each theme (as predictors) to community belonging and integration (as dependent variables).

Studentification is established as an interdisciplinary process. It encompasses four dimensions: Social, Cultural, Economic, and Physical. In this, interdisciplinary skills were of importance. To build upon the literature on studentification, I used separate resources from the disciplines: economics, sociology, psychology, anthropology, and urban geography.

Through using an exploratory sequential mixed methods design, my study had a natural progression and built upon itself as it evolved - the synthesis was organic and emergent through my findings; notably the cohesivity between my two methods and the literature read.

Proposal/Outcome

The study found that four themes had a significant relationship with belonging and integration. These were: Economic practice, recreation, decoration and amenity. Decoration and amenity are focussed more on the inside of the student home and economic practice and recreation focus on how in line out-of-home behaviours are with the local community.

As such, my product is a campaign strategy detailing an initiative that LIS could use to integrate its students into local communities, so that students feel a sense of belonging towards Tower Hamlets.

Beyond Outcomes

Hard thought pays off! Thinking through something deeply, being as aware as you can about the content you’re researching and working with your work rather than against it gives the most impactful results!

All of this has given me work I am proud to stand behind, regardless of final grade.

Want to learn more about this project?

Here is some student work from their formal assignments. Please note it may contain errors or unfinished elements. It is shared to offer insights into our programme and build a knowledge exchange community.

Summary

Methods
Ethnography
Data Science
Disciplinary perspectives
Environmental Geography
Social Psychology

Studentification is a large issue within University cities today. Commonly thought as the first step to gentrification, studentification is the process by which the sociospatial makeup of an area changes due to an influx of students from a nearby higher education provider. This issue commonly is treated as an ‘us v.s. them’ issue, pitting local communities and students against one another.

I argue that this isn’t how it should be. I hypothesise that the transient nature of being a student affects the ability to feel a sense of community belonging, and as such any opportunities for community integration. This then leads to the issues surrounding community resilience, cohesion and displacement students are typically blamed for.

This project opens dialogue between these groups, and in the process of doing so, finds some overarching problem areas stemming from student transience that could be tackled.

Approach and Methodology

In September, there is an increasing amount of change happening for students at higher education providers; from haggling deposits back, moving to completely new areas with new sets of people to beginning the new academic year at university. This study came to me from this context, whereby I was witnessing a disparity between my peers who hadn’t constantly moved throughout our time at university, and those that had.

This context was paired with moving to Peckham myself, an area in the midst of atypical urban regeneration stemming from gentrification - current Southwark council plans include creating large multi-story apartment housing (of which only 20% will be affordable) in the centre of Rye Lane, the cultural heart of Peckham. As well as having had multiple conversations with acquaintances involved in the save Brick Lane campaign. The impact the system surrounding student has on both students and local communities is a context I am inescapably embedded in - the study came from this.

The accessibility of this topic allowed for me to use ethnography as my qualitative method. I had already read a lot about studentification at this point; so sent out an invite to my social network to participate in my study. The ethnographic methods chosen were hyper-local demarcation (Joy White’s method involving analysing a local area through the overarching themes: town-planning, soundscapes, legislation and community) and intimate conversations which emerged authentically throughout the process of being taken around my friends’ homes and local areas.

From the ethnographic fieldwork, six themes emerged: Economic practice, recreation, decoration, amenity, maintenance and cleanliness and temporal artefacts. More information was then gathered on these six themes using a survey I created and sent through my social network. The results of this survey was then analysed using multiple linear regression and ANOVA testing for statistical significance of the relationship of each theme (as predictors) to community belonging and integration (as dependent variables).

Studentification is established as an interdisciplinary process. It encompasses four dimensions: Social, Cultural, Economic, and Physical. In this, interdisciplinary skills were of importance. To build upon the literature on studentification, I used separate resources from the disciplines: economics, sociology, psychology, anthropology, and urban geography.

Through using an exploratory sequential mixed methods design, my study had a natural progression and built upon itself as it evolved - the synthesis was organic and emergent through my findings; notably the cohesivity between my two methods and the literature read.

Heading 1

Heading 2

Heading 3

Heading 4

Heading 5
Heading 6

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur.

Block quote

Ordered list

  1. Item 1
  2. Item 2
  3. Item 3

Unordered list

  • Item A
  • Item B
  • Item C

Text link

Bold text

Emphasis

Superscript

Subscript

Beyond Outcomes

Hard thought pays off! Thinking through something deeply, being as aware as you can about the content you’re researching and working with your work rather than against it gives the most impactful results!

All of this has given me work I am proud to stand behind, regardless of final grade.

Proposal/Outcome

The study found that four themes had a significant relationship with belonging and integration. These were: Economic practice, recreation, decoration and amenity. Decoration and amenity are focussed more on the inside of the student home and economic practice and recreation focus on how in line out-of-home behaviours are with the local community.

As such, my product is a campaign strategy detailing an initiative that LIS could use to integrate its students into local communities, so that students feel a sense of belonging towards Tower Hamlets.

Want to learn more about this project?

Here is some student work from their formal assignments. Please note it may contain errors or unfinished elements. It is shared to offer insights into our programme and build a knowledge exchange community.

Author's Final Reflection

When I met Phoebe Waller-Bridge (name-drop) in the Starbucks opposite LIS she seemed intent on asking me questions about how I was finding Whitechapel as an area. At the time - as a first year more enamoured by other, shinier areas in London - I didn’t understand why she didn’t want to talk about more interesting things. I’d forgotten about this, but in writing this up I’ve remembered: I think I see her point now.

As someone who has fallen in love with Whitechapel (and tower hamlets in general), I think there is a responsibility to cherish the local community, culture and history that we, as LIS students, are now a part of. And we’ll feel a lot more grounded and warm if we do too!

You don’t feel belonging - you find belonging. I hope my study and product capture that.

Overall LIS Journey

Academic References

Further Information

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur. Pharetra vestibulum praesent sapien bibendum id egestas leo pellentesque adipiscing.

View the full project

About me

Ideator of unfinished thoughts and speaker of imaginative truths. Founding cohort @ LIS in interdisciplinary problems and methods. Championing collective intelligence to curate forces of innovative solution. Problem solving enthusiast and earnest writer.

Other Related Projects

Language, Learning, and YouTube

Automating the CEFR Assessment of User-like Generated videos for Language Learning

Education
Community-Scale Plastic Recycling Workspaces

From Waste to Resource: A Cost Model for Efficient Community-Scale Plastic Recycling

Waste
Community
Community Land Ownership and Native Woodland Restoration

Investigating Community-Owned Forest Initiatives as a Vehicle for Native Woodland Restoration in the Scottish Highlands: A Case Study Approach

Nature
Community
Climate